The Milburn Report – some random reflections

It seems to me that the report has lots of great ideas on the supply side, but not so many when it comes to explaining how to create the demand for workers in the parts of the country where there are the highest levels of NEETs, and fewest vacancies. This morning the BBC ran a table of vacancies by district councils – Oxfordshire Councils filled the top three places, with a fourth in 10th place. Only Oxford City was well down the list. Where are the most jobs for 18-24 year-olds? – BBC News

So what did I pick out of the report? Here are some random reflections.

A top Milburn outcome:

  1. “Within 10 years, all of those young people who can participate, whether in education, training or employment, should be doing so. The first milestone in this longer journey should be to ensure that no 16 to 17 year-old is NEET. By law, in England, none of them should be.”

As a reminder, this is what the government says about the school leaving age:

Your school leaving age depends on where you live.

England

You can leave school on the last Friday in June if you’ll be 16 by the end of the summer holidays.

You must then do one of the following until you’re 18:

  • stay in full-time education, for example at a college
  • start an apprenticeship
  • spend 20 hours or more a week working or volunteering, while in part-time education or training

School leaving age – GOV.UK

But what it doesn’t say is there is no penalty for disobeying the law. Should there now be a penalty for not being in one of the three categories, assuming there is no medical reason?  This would place 16-18 year-olds in a different category from children between 5-16, where the requirement is education, and not to attend school. Where would this place home schoolers after 16?

Now for a Milburn comment that this blog has been saying since its creation in 2013, and has been true for as long as I have been involved in schooling.

“Schools serving some of the communities with the greatest concentrations of disadvantage and later youth detachment can find it hardest to recruit and retain experienced staff.[footnote 226] Teacher shortages and weaker school quality overlap with areas of higher deprivation.[footnote 227]”

But what is the solution. Abandon the market principle for teacher vacancies, and direct teachers where to work. The report talks about academy trusts pooling teacher expertise, but I couldn’t find anything about local authority schools. Milburn doesn’t consider the fragmentation of Trusts across some places, and whether a more rational place-based system of school governance, as in the past, might be more sensible.

With falling rolls, will new teachers be willing to be told where to work and directed towards the most disadvantaged schools? I doubt it. The coalition tried to place teachers in schools, but the trial never made it beyond the drawing board. Will this government decide to take such a step or just ignore the problem of staffing schools in the areas of greatest disadvantage?

It was good to see the comments about both early years and pre-schooling, but the government faces the same issues as with 16-18, participation is not mandatory whatever words are used.

“397. To achieve this more substantial shift in early years outcomes, there needs to be a strengthened birth-to-5 system. This should include sustained expansion of Best Start Family Hubs, particularly in areas of high disadvantage and isolation, and more local capacity in local authorities and MSAs to join up services from conception to age 5.[footnote 284]””

There is a separate chapter about the NHS, perhaps this section on early years is where there could have been more comment about cross-sector working?

Retuning to the teaching labour force, the report seems to both blame schools and suggest government involvement

“413. A participation strategy which expects more from schools serving the most disadvantaged communities must pay attention to whether those schools have the workforce and leadership capacity required to deliver it. Government should use its existing teacher recruitment, retention and school-improvement levers more deliberately in the places where educational disadvantage and later youth detachment overlap. Existing school-improvement capacity, including Regional Improvements for Standards and Excellence (RISE) teams, should be used in schools and places with persistently weak participation and NEET outcomes.[footnote 305] Government should report annually on whether the gaps in educational attainment by geography as well as by socio-economic group are narrowing or widening. Alongside its annual report it should identify how it is deploying financial and human resources to close those attainment gaps.” My bolding of the text

I am not clear what levers the Report is thinking of. I suggested above that the market principle doesn’t work at present in filling vacancies and attracting teachers to the schools in the most deprived areas. If the thinking is to offer more money to work in such schools, then the report should have said so, and not hidden behind such vague terminology as ‘levers’.

Finally, this caught my eye.

“423. The UTC model should also be expanded. There are currently 44 UTCs in England, representing around 1% of state-funded secondary schools.[footnote 321] A recent analysis found that UTC leavers were more likely to enter apprenticeships and more likely to be employed.[footnote 322] Mainstream secondary schools are already beginning to build on the model by adopting the ‘UTC Sleeve’ approach.[footnote 323] This model embeds the specialist, employer-led technical approach of a UTC within an existing secondary school. It too should become over time a mainstream part of the school landscape.”

I am delighted that the current UTCs, or those that have survived, are apparently flourishing, but if there are no jobs or apprenticeships this a supply-side initiative that like so much of the report creates a better system, but doesn’t ensure the jobs will be there across the country.

Living in Oxfordshire, there should be little or no reason to be a NEET, but living in parts of the north of England, it is a different story.

How about an AI tax on employers that is levied on every job lost through the use of AI? That cash could help by taxing the firms that are helping create the NEETs.

Leave a Reply